GetFreeCarCheck

Research · DVSA MOT data 2022–2024

The UK cars most likely to fail their first MOT

12.3% of cars fail their first MOT: about one in 8, across 7,348,122 MOTs at three years old. Among Britain's 100 most common models, the Dacia Sandero fails its first MOT 2.9 times as often as the Honda Jazz (19.5% against 6.7%).

All cars at their first MOT

12.3%

7,348,122 MOTs at three years old

Most likely to fail: Dacia Sandero

19.5%

1.6× the average: the highest of Britain's 100 most common cars

Least likely to fail: Honda Jazz

6.7%

about one in 15 fails: the lowest of the 100

Key findings

What the first MOT tells you

  • 12.3% of cars fail their first MOT: about one in 8, across 7,348,122 MOTs at three years old.
  • Among Britain's 100 most common models, the Dacia Sandero fails its first MOT 2.9 times as often as the Honda Jazz (19.5% against 6.7%).
  • The Vauxhall Corsa fails 18.2% of first MOTs, against 9.7% for the Volkswagen Golf, even though it arrives with fewer miles (23,355 against 28,702).
  • Britain's most common three-year-old car, the Ford Fiesta, fails 11.9% of first MOTs, close to the national 12.3%.
  • Vans fail 22.7% of first MOTs, 2.1 times the family SUV rate (10.8%).
  • By make, Porsche fails the fewest first MOTs (5.1%) and Dacia the most (18.7%).

Buying a car that's nearly three? Its first MOT is close. Check its MOT history free, or see whether it has finance owing or has been written off with a full history check.

The cars you see every day

Britain's 20 most common cars at their first MOT

Fail rate at the first attempt, at three years old. "vs all cars" compares each with the national 12.3%: 1.50× fails half as often again.

First MOT fail rate for the 20 most common cars
#CarTypeFirst MOTsFail ratevs all carsMedian miles
1Ford FiestaSmall car221,17011.9%0.97×22,825
2Vauxhall CorsaSmall car165,27818.2%1.48×23,355
3Volkswagen GolfFamily hatchback163,8009.7%0.79×28,702
4Ford FocusFamily hatchback148,46012.1%0.98×27,644
5MINI HatchSmall car148,0209.7%0.79×21,029
6Mercedes-Benz A-ClassFamily hatchback147,11010.7%0.87×27,766
7Nissan QashqaiFamily SUV135,92110.5%0.85×26,583
8Volkswagen PoloSmall car112,85211.7%0.95×23,540
9Volkswagen TiguanFamily SUV103,26210.7%0.87×30,039
10Ford KugaFamily SUV100,68511.1%0.90×26,671
11BMW 1 SeriesFamily hatchback97,5149.7%0.79×27,863
12Kia SportageFamily SUV91,14313.9%1.13×27,238
13BMW 3 SeriesExecutive car87,68711.5%0.93×34,563
14Toyota YarisSmall car83,42510.4%0.85×19,348
15Audi A3Family hatchback72,16510.2%0.83×28,754
16Volvo XC40Small SUV71,3978.8%0.72×28,257
17Hyundai TucsonFamily SUV69,52613.7%1.11×26,921
18Land Rover Range Rover EvoqueFamily SUV68,58410.7%0.87×26,619
19Nissan JukeSmall SUV67,67713.5%1.10×22,096
20Volkswagen T-RocSmall SUV65,7898.1%0.66×26,638

Common models

Most and least likely to fail, among common cars

Models with 20,000+ first MOTs: 100 cars that make up most of the three-year-olds on sale.

Most likely to fail

Common cars most likely to fail their first MOT
#CarFail ratevs all cars
1Dacia Sandero19.5%1.59×
2Vauxhall Corsa18.2%1.48×
3Dacia Duster17.6%1.43×
4Land Rover Discovery Sport16.1%1.31×
5Renault Clio16.1%1.31×
6Kia Ceed14.7%1.20×
7Tesla Model 314.5%1.18×
8Renault Kadjar14.3%1.16×
9Land Rover Range Rover Velar14.1%1.15×
10Kia Sportage13.9%1.13×

Least likely to fail

Common cars least likely to fail their first MOT
#CarFail ratevs all cars
1Honda Jazz6.7%0.54×
2Jaguar I-Pace6.7%0.54×
3Audi Q37.3%0.59×
4Ford Puma7.5%0.61×
5Honda CR-V7.5%0.61×
6Audi Q27.8%0.63×
7Volkswagen T-Roc8.1%0.66×
8Audi Q58.1%0.66×
9Toyota RAV48.2%0.67×
10Land Rover Range Rover8.4%0.68×

By car type and make

Which cars fail their first MOT most

Types weight every model by its first MOTs; makes cover cars only (vans left out), each with 10,000+ first MOTs, from fewest fails to most.

By car type

  • Sports cars and convertibles6.6%69,908 first MOTs
  • Luxury cars7.5%27,754 first MOTs
  • Large SUVs10.1%273,254 first MOTs
  • Small SUVs10.6%1,175,987 first MOTs
  • Family SUVs10.8%1,408,495 first MOTs
  • City cars11.1%335,863 first MOTs
  • Family hatchbacks11.3%1,220,073 first MOTs
  • Executive cars11.3%461,021 first MOTs
  • Small cars12.4%1,248,639 first MOTs
  • Large family cars14.4%181,389 first MOTs
  • Pickups16.8%138,231 first MOTs
  • MPVs and people carriers17.5%97,968 first MOTs
  • Vans22.7%558,857 first MOTs

All vehicles

By make

  • Porsche5.1%46,366 first MOTs
  • Lexus6.6%45,143 first MOTs
  • Honda7.7%122,428 first MOTs
  • Audi9.1%429,162 first MOTs
  • Mazda9.3%103,398 first MOTs
  • Suzuki9.6%59,348 first MOTs
  • MINI9.9%191,324 first MOTs
  • BMW10.3%504,604 first MOTs
  • Mercedes-Benz10.5%450,003 first MOTs
  • Toyota10.5%331,780 first MOTs
  • Volkswagen10.5%556,470 first MOTs
  • Volvo10.5%175,294 first MOTs
  • Jaguar10.9%113,466 first MOTs
  • Skoda11.2%218,175 first MOTs
  • Nissan11.4%272,731 first MOTs
  • Fiat11.6%76,418 first MOTs
  • Land Rover11.6%252,816 first MOTs
  • SEAT11.8%178,848 first MOTs
  • Abarth11.9%11,397 first MOTs
  • Ford11.9%651,301 first MOTs
  • Citroën12.2%120,721 first MOTs
  • Hyundai12.4%228,999 first MOTs
  • Mitsubishi12.6%43,500 first MOTs
  • Kia12.7%267,266 first MOTs
  • Peugeot13.1%217,423 first MOTs
  • MG13.5%49,881 first MOTs
  • Renault14%159,511 first MOTs
  • Tesla14.5%64,511 first MOTs
  • Vauxhall14.9%421,435 first MOTs
  • Dacia18.7%73,209 first MOTs

All cars

Every model

The full ranking: 20 highest and 20 lowest

All 264 car models with 1,000+ first MOTs. The full list, vans included, is in the CSV.

Highest first MOT fail rates

Highest first MOT fail rates, all ranked cars
#CarFail ratevs all cars
1Hyundai i80030.8%2.50×
2Ford Grand C-Max22%1.79×
3Dacia Logan21.7%1.76×
4Citroën Spacetourer21.5%1.75×
5Ford Tourneo Custom20.7%1.68×
6Renault Grand Scenic20%1.63×
7Kia Carens20%1.63×
8Dacia Sandero19.5%1.59×
9Renault Megane19.3%1.57×
10Peugeot Rifter19.2%1.56×
11Vauxhall Zafira19.2%1.56×
12Citroën C4 Grand Picasso19.1%1.55×
13Vauxhall Adam18.8%1.53×
14Fiat Tipo18.8%1.53×
15Ford Galaxy18.7%1.52×
16Vauxhall Insignia18.4%1.50×
17Vauxhall Corsa18.2%1.48×
18Ford Tourneo Connect18.2%1.48×
19Peugeot 50818.1%1.47×
20SsangYong Korando17.8%1.45×

Lowest first MOT fail rates

Lowest first MOT fail rates, all ranked cars
#CarFail ratevs all cars
1Aston Martin DBS1.7%0.14×
2Bentley Bentayga3.2%0.26×
3Porsche Cayman3.7%0.30×
4Aston Martin DB114%0.33×
5Aston Martin Vantage4%0.33×
6Bentley Continental4.2%0.34×
7BMW M34.4%0.36×
8Porsche 9114.4%0.36×
9Lexus RX4.5%0.37×
10Porsche Boxster4.7%0.38×
11Porsche Macan5.2%0.42×
12Toyota GT865.3%0.43×
13Porsche Cayenne5.5%0.45×
14Lexus UX5.6%0.46×
15Mazda MX-55.8%0.47×
16Land Rover Defender5.8%0.47×
17Audi S36.1%0.50×
18Lexus NX6.1%0.50×
19Mercedes-Benz S-Class6.2%0.50×
20Mercedes-Benz SL6.3%0.51×

Sports and luxury cars top the lowest list partly because they cover few miles. For a like-for-like view that adjusts for age and mileage, see the MOT Reliability Index.

Vans and pickups

Vans at their first MOT

The 12 most common vans and pickups. Vans work hard and fail far more often than cars.

First MOT fail rate for the most common vans and pickups
#CarTypeFirst MOTsFail ratevs all carsMedian miles
1Ford Transit CustomVan119,78720.4%1.66×48,793
2Volkswagen TransporterVan55,26816.3%1.33×37,712
3Ford RangerPickup48,61116.4%1.33×41,355
4Citroën BerlingoVan45,49428.6%2.33×43,266
5Vauxhall ComboVan41,19629.2%2.37×42,207
6Ford Transit ConnectVan41,11023.7%1.93×48,664
7Peugeot PartnerVan39,13226.4%2.15×50,023
8Vauxhall VivaroVan33,83424.7%2.01×50,125
9Volkswagen CaddyVan29,33718.7%1.52×42,628
10Nissan NavaraPickup24,47818%1.46×41,987
11Mitsubishi L200Pickup21,71914.7%1.20×38,619
12Renault TraficVan20,13422%1.79×47,497

Method

How we worked it out

Source: the DVSA's anonymised MOT tests and results for 2022–2024, every normal class 4 test in Great Britain (cars, people carriers and vans up to 3,000kg). Retests are left out, so each MOT counts once.

First MOT means a test 3 to 4 years after the car was first registered: nearly all are first MOTs, which fall due on the third anniversary. A first MOT taken a few weeks early counts at age two and sits outside these figures. Fail rate is the share of tests that failed at the first attempt; a car that passed after a repair during the test (PRS) counts as a fail, the industry standard.

A model is ranked with 1,000+ first MOTs, and only models with 5,000+ MOTs in all are covered (350 models, 7,217,044 of 7,348,122 first MOTs). Models whose median mileage at age three is over 60,000 are left out of the rankings, because they are not typical three-year-old cars: LEVC TX Vista, LEVC TX, Nissan Elgrand, Toyota Alphard, Toyota Estima, Toyota Prius+ (Japanese imports and taxis). They stay in the CSV. Make and type figures weight each model by its number of first MOTs.

The numbers on this page come straight from our build of the DVSA data, rebuilt when the DVSA publishes a new year. More on the method: how the Reliability Index works, where our data comes from and our editorial policy.

Use this data

Free to quote and reuse

Quote any figure with a link to this page: “Source: GetFreeCarCheck analysis of DVSA MOT data, 2022–2024.” The model-level data is a free CSV download, archived with a DOI at doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24358242 and on Hugging Face and Kaggle.

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0, from the DVSA. Our derived figures are under the same licence.

Questions

First MOT questions, answered

Which car is most likely to fail its first MOT?

Among the 100 most common models on UK roads, the Dacia Sandero: 19.5% of its first MOTs end in a fail, against 12.3% for all cars. Across every model with 1,000+ first MOTs, the Hyundai i800 fails most often (30.8%).

Which cars are least likely to fail their first MOT?

Among common models: the Honda Jazz (6.7%), Jaguar I-Pace (6.7%), Audi Q3 (7.3%). Low-mileage sports and luxury cars fail even less often: the Aston Martin DBS fails 1.7%.

What percentage of cars fail their first MOT?

12.3% of cars fail their MOT at three years old, about one in 8. That counts a fail at the first attempt, including cars that passed after a repair during the test. The typical car has done 27,360 miles by then.

When is a car's first MOT due?

In England, Scotland and Wales, three years after the car was first registered. You can take it up to a month (minus a day) early and keep the same renewal date. In Northern Ireland the first MOT is at four years.

Does a high first-MOT fail rate mean a car is unreliable?

It means more of those cars needed work to be roadworthy at three years old: tyres, brakes, lights and suspension cause most fails. How a car is looked after matters too, so check the MOT history of the exact car you're buying. It's free by registration.

Check any car's MOT history. It's free.

MOT history, mileage record, ULEZ, tax and recalls on any UK car, in seconds. No sign-up, no card.